Amulets of Power (2011)
Veterans vs. Rookies (2012)
Robbie made it just before merge in his first season, and his game plans took a drastic turn for the worse in an unexpected tribe swap.
In Veterans vs. Rookies, Robbie's strong bond with Jake, Travis, and Katie would propel them deep into the game. In the Past Challenge Finale Relay, Robbie lost the final stage of the puzzle building to Katie. She subsequently voted Robbie out because she was unsure if she could get more votes than him in the end.